if the feather fits

Toby

Toby took Spencer’s fucking virginity and then turns out to be the fucking betrayer. what the actual fuck. i’m literally shaking & in shock right now. can’t. breathe.

‘A’ Theory

Mona was NOT dressed as the black swan. Aria was.

send me your pretty little theories! xo

if yours is amazing, i will promo you :) 

send me your pretty little theories! xo

if yours is really good, i’ll promo you :)

‘A’ Theory

 my theory about WHO KILLED ALLISON.

• Lolita: A story about an older man who loves young girls. Byron is older. Ali is…was younger.
• The Earring: Ali “found” the earring aka placed the earring in the couch OR dropped it herself when she was with Byron.
• Aria and The Earring: Why are we putting our dad’s mistresses earrings in our dead friend’s casket? Maybe because the earring belonged to Ali and Aria wanted closure from the affair that her friend was having with her dad.
• The Montgomery family goes on vacation: WTF. We need to go to Iceland….Why? SO NO ONE KNOWS MY DAD KILLED OUR BEST FRIEND.
• Yo, Mike, what’s up with sneaking out?: Mike is conflicted! He is trying to cover/figure out if his dad really did kill Allison.

So, basically, Byron had an affair with Ali and he killed her because she’s a manipulative psycho bitch.

‘A’ Theory

Reasons why Aria could be ‘A’

1. aria’s relationship is the only one that hasn’t been fucked up by A. aria and ezra decided THEMSELVES that they would tell her parents about it. the only thing that doesn’t make sense about this is that A sent their dad that letter telling him where her and ezra would be.

2. aria was the last one who had vivian darkbloom’s red jacket and at the end of the finale, the girl who mona was talking to had a red jacket. i know a lot of people are saying it could be alison, but why would she have two red jackets that look identical?

3. someone was dressed up as the black swan at the masquerade ball, and if you paid attention to aria’s dress, it was red and black just like the black swan movie poster or whatever.

4. she’s the only one out of the girls who hasn’t been physically hurt by A. A hasn’t even touched aria in a harmful way…

5. she always seems to be somewhere else whenever something really major happens with the girls.

6. A didn’t start sending them messages until aria returned from iceland.

7. alison has never visited aria like she has emily, hanna and spencer.

8. she’s clearly the best liar out of everyone.

9. in one of the episodes she really had no issue telling her mom that she was going to turn in her dad for having an affair with his student, which would get him fired. A has no problem blackmailing and manipulating the girls, and apparently aria has no problem doing it to her own family.

10. in the episode where they get the dolls, A actually HELPED aria by telling her to get rid of jackie. but all of the other girls had to do something that would ruin their relationship.

11. in the episode where A tells aria’s mom about byron’s affair with the student, the letter was written with a typewriter. aria has easy access to a typewriter since ezra has one. and also since byron begged aria not to tell her mom, it could have just been aria who sent it as A so byron wouldn’t get pissed at her.

‘A’ Theory

• Spencer’s doll said “Keep Toby safe” In order to keep Toby safe, Spencer needs to break up with him. That leads to Wren and Spencer happening since Wren’s only problem was/is Toby.
• Wren owns a fireplace in his apartment, and in an episode in season 1, A burns a log saying “Ali + Ian”
• Wren has an interest in younger girls, and Ali had an interest in older men. Was something going on?
• In 1x02, Wren is being escorted by Spencer to his motel room. A rented a motel room in the episode; A person of Interest
• In the episode; Over my dead body, A is seen flipping a tea cup while sitting in front of Dr. Sullivan, and in a flashback Wren said “How about some tea” to Spencer.
• In 2x23 Jenna said to Toby “Even lying would sound good in that accent” This was said about Wren.
• Wren would easily know about the lake house, since he was once engaged to Melissa, who also has access to it.
• In an interview with A the question is: You seem to break up the couples, why of the girls boyfriends are you most interested in? A: Toby. Wren is interested in Spencer, and Toby was her then boyfriend.
• In 2x07, It shows that A owns syringes and has HGH, which can be found in hospitals.
• Some hospitals use rats for lab experiments, seeing as though he works at a hospital that could easily explain the rats in A’s apartment in episode; The Bad Seed
• He’s a doctor, meaning he gets paid loads, that explains A’s amount of money.
• He lived in the Hastings household, meaning he had a lot of access to it, so he could have just easily stole Peter Hastings’ gun.
• Nosey Bitches Die was written for the girls, Nosey is the British spelling, and Wren is British.
• He is a doctor, and has access to the Hospital, and he could have just had easily have access to the Morgue. 
• This was in an interview with A; Q: What’s your New Years resolution? A: More Cardio. 
• In the pilot Wren gives Spencer a massage, and in another episode “A” gives Emily a massage.

*these theories were not just found by me, credit goes to whoever else thought of these*